Skip to main content

Table 3 Population characteristics of included studies

From: Outcomes of autologous chondrocyte transplantation (ACT) and autologous matrix-induced chondrogenesis (AMIC) in the hip: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Author

Year

Study Design

Procedure

Level of Evidence

Number of patients/hips

Sex M/F

Age in years ± SD (Range)

Follow up period months ± SD (Range)

Schroeder et al [41]

2016

Prospective case series

ACT

4

20/21

16/4

33

(22–49)

12.05

(6–24)

Krueger et al [42]

2021

Retrospective case series

ACT

4

36/36

31/5

32.9

(18–49)

29.9

(24–42)

Bretschneider et al [39]

2019

Prospective case series

ACT

4

21/21

17/4

32.3 ± 10 (20–53)

12

Thier et al [43]

2017

Retrospective case series

ACT

4

29/29

27/2

30.3 ± 6.9

19 (6–24)

Krueger et al [44]

2018

Retrospective case series

ACT

4

32/32

28/4

32 (18–49)

35.5 (24–49)

Mancini, Fontana [32]

2014

Retrospective Case control series

ACT

3

26/26

12/14

36 ± 9.3

60

AMIC

3

31/31

13/18

36.4 ± 10.3

60

Briem et al [45]

2024

Retrospective case series

AMIC

4

11/12

10/1

26.8 (5.0)

74 ± 5.2

Thorey et al [46]

2020

Retrospective case series

AMIC

4

62/62

28/34

34.3 ± 5.4 (18–44)

25 (24–27)

de Girolamo et al [47]

2018

Retrospective case series

AMIC

3

59/59

27/32

39.3 (18–55)

96

Villarrubia et al [48]

2022

Retrospective case series

AMIC

4

25/28

19/6

40.5 ± 7.1 (25–55)

29 (24–48)

Fontana [49]

2016

Retrospective, non-randomised study

AMIC

4

201/201

84/117

36.4 ± 10.3

48

Fontana and de Girolamo [50]

2015

Retrospective, non-randomised study

AMIC

3

70/70

36/34

39.1

(18–55)

60